This story seems to slipped past the local news media, but I thought it was worth noting.
For those who aren’t in the loop, there’s a big issue in Delaware County right now about proposed flight path changes for planes leaving the Philly airport. The new paths would allow the airport to increase the number of outgoing flights by allowing many planes to turn for their westward destinations right over central Delco. Currently, they are prohibited from doing so.
Although it is a federal issue under the jurisdiction of the FAA, no candidate has made more political noise about the issue than State Rep. Tom Gannon, PA-161. Through mass mailings, web pages, and meetings, Gannon has annointed himself the FAA gladiator, mostly by telling residents repeatedly that they are likely to experience up to 1000% increases in noise if the flight path changes are put into effect.
Swarthmore College Associate Professor of Engineering Carr Everbach is an area resident and a specialist in acoustical engineering. He has recently called into question how the FAA data has been presented. It turns out that while the noise levels experienced on the ground would obviously go up, the perceived noise level, which is best measured in units called sones, might double at worst.
As a person who lives right under the flight path, I don’t want a lot more planes flying overhead. I expect that ANY elected official for this district would help us to question and challenge the FAA plan. In fact, both of the area’s Republican incumbents (Gannon and Weldon) and the Democratic challengers (Lentz and Sestak) have indicated that they would do exactly that. As far as I’m concerned, it’s an issue for residents, but not an election issue.
But I also don’t want my elected officials hyping the situation out of control. Gannon runs the risk of creating a real estate panic. (And what will the flight path of all those residents be, if they think their houses might end up beseiged with noise in a year?)
Kudos to Swarthmore College student reporter Tally Sharma, who wrote the only piece I’ve found on the issue. From her article in the Swarthmore student newspaper, the Phoenix, here are a few of the choice quotes from Prof. Everbach:
Everbach said that he believed that this misrepresentation of information was merely a result of unawareness. “There will be some embarrassment,” he said. “I would like to believe that it’s a product of ignorance all around”
Everbach did say, however, that some people’s misapprehension of the situation might have allowed the issue to be blown out of proportion. “Based on their incorrect understanding, some politicians such as Tom Gannon and, to an extent, Curt Weldon have circulated [this information] at taxpayers’ expense,” he said.
Truthful telling of the facts is critical if we’re to make informed decisions as citizens. If Gannon were a decent fellow, he’d immediately and publicly correct his error. There’s a noise that I don’t expect to hear.
As my friend and future legislator Bryan Lentz aptly says: “Leaders should not incite fear; they should encourage solutions.”